Why women Should Stop Sleeping on Creatine

If you ask some women about creatine, you'll probably still get one of two reactions from them: either complete confusion ("Isn't that for guys who want huge muscles?") or immediate dismissal ("I heard it makes your hair fall out"). Here's the thing though, both reactions are based on outdated myths, and women are missing out on one of the most researched and beneficial supplements available.

Let's set the record straight about creatine and why it deserves a spot in your nutrition routine, no matter what decade of life you're in.

Photo by Aleksander Saks (Unsplash)

The Real Story Behind Creatine

For years, creatine has been marketed almost exclusively to men looking to build muscle and boost gym performance. That narrow focus meant researchers largely ignored half the population. Women's bodies work differently than men's, we have distinct hormonal fluctuations throughout our cycles, during pregnancy, and through menopause. These changes affect how we produce, store, and use creatine.

Recent research has finally started filling in these gaps, and the findings are really cool to learn about. Women naturally produce about 20% less creatine than men and typically consume 30-40% less through diet (especially if you don't eat much meat, which you should!!). Beyond just helping with workouts, creatine plays important roles in brain function, mood regulation, bone health, and energy metabolism which are all areas where women face unique challenges throughout life.

What the Latest Research Found

A comprehensive review published in the Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition examined decades of creatine research specific to women. The researchers looked at everything from how menstrual cycles affect creatine metabolism to its potential benefits during menopause.

What is really exciting is that creatine isn't just about building bigger biceps. The research shows creatine supplementation can help with muscle strength and exercise performance (particularly when combined with resistance training), but it also influences cognitive function, mood, sleep quality, and even cellular health. Some studies found that women taking creatine during their luteal phase (or the second half of the menstrual cycle) experienced better fluid balance and less of that uncomfortable bloating feeling many women report.

The review also highlighted emerging evidence around bone health for post-menopausal women and potential cognitive benefits across all ages. On the other hand, researchers are now investigating creatine's role during pregnancy, though this area is still in early research stages.

What This Means for You

Let's make this practical. Here's how creatine can fit into your life, depending on where you are:

In Your 30s and 40s: during this period of life, life can become very busy: career demands, maybe kids, aging parents, and that creeping fatigue that seems harder to shake. Creatine can help maintain your energy during workouts, support recovery, and keep your strength up. If you're noticing that your gym sessions feel harder or you're more tired than usual, creatine helps your cells produce energy more efficiently. Think of it as keeping your cellular batteries charged.

One practical swap: instead of relying solely on another coffee for that 3 PM slump, proper creatine supplementation alongside resistance training can improve your overall energy capacity throughout the day.

Approaching or In Perimenopause (40s-50s): this phase is when hormonal changes really start affecting everything like muscle mass, bone density, mood, sleep, and that annoying brain fog. Creatine supplementation combined with resistance training can help counter the muscle loss that accelerates during this time (about 1.5 pounds per year). It may also support better sleep quality, especially after training days, and help with that frustrating feeling of mental fogginess.

Real-life application: if you're struggling with the intensity of your workouts or noticing your strength declining, creatine provides the extra support your changing body needs to maintain what you've built.

Post-Menopause: the research here is actually the strongest. Studies show that post-menopausal women who combine creatine with resistance training see significant improvements in bone health, muscle mass, and strength. This will not only help you stay fit but it will also reduce fracture risk and maintain independence as you age.

A Note on Pregnancy: while animal studies and early human research show promising results for creatine during pregnancy, mainly for fetal brain development and protection against birth complications, this is still an active area of research. If you're pregnant or planning to become pregnant, talk with your doctor or GP about whether creatine is right for you.

Let's Bust Those Myths

"Won't creatine make me bulky?" euuuuh NO! Here's the truth: there's no such thing as "accidentally bulky." Building significant muscle mass requires consistent heavy lifting, eating in a caloric surplus, and usually years of dedicated training. Creatine helps you perform better during workouts and recover more effectively, which supports your training goals whatever there are. If you're eating in a deficit to lose fat, creatine won't make you bulky. It might help you hold onto muscle while you're in that deficit, which is exactly what you want.

"Isn't creatine just for men?" This myth exists because early research focused almost entirely on men. But women's bodies make and use creatine too, we even start with lower stores and get less from our diets. That means we potentially have even more to gain from supplementation.

"Will it make my hair fall out?" This persistent myth comes from a single study that didn't even measure hair loss. The study showed a change in DHT (a hormone related to hair loss in people genetically predisposed), but no actual hair loss occurred. Decades of research since then have found no connection between creatine and hair loss. If you're worried about your hair, I can guarantee creatine isn't the culprit.

So How to Use It then?

Supplementing with creatine is straightforward. You can either "load" with 20 grams per day (split into four 5-gram doses) for 5-7 days, then maintain with 3-5 grams daily, or skip loading and just take 3-5 grams every day (it'll take 3-4 weeks to build up your stores this way). Both approaches work, loading just gets you there faster. Mix it with water, coffee, or a protein shake or whatever you like. Consistency matters more than timing. Creatine is not supposed to taste weird, so you should not worry about a different taste.

Quick Takeaways

• Creatine isn't just for building muscle, it supports energy, brain function, bone health, and mood across all life stages

• Women naturally produce less creatine and consume less through diet, making supplementation potentially more beneficial

• The "bulky" myth is just that: a myth. Creatine supports whatever training goals you have

• Taking 3-5 grams daily is a simple, research-backed approach that works for most women, I know some women go up to 20g, I personally do 5-8g a day

• If you're in your 30s-50s and struggling with energy, strength, or the effects of hormonal changes, creatine is worth considering

Creatine isn't a magic pill, but it's one of the most thoroughly researched, safe, and effective supplements available. I will not suggest any brand in this blog, but before you purchase creatine, make sure to verify it is legit.

Managing multiple metabolic conditions can feel overwhelming. Let's create a personalised nutrition and fitness plan that actually works for your health goals and lifestyle.

Schedule your consultation today.